Aliens, Magic Rocks, and Super Toothpaste


April 1st, 2016 Episode 43 Hi and welcome to the brainstorm podcast. This is episode 43 and today is April 1st, 2016. I’m Cory and my panel tonight are Destin, Angela, and Rene, with the always amazing Dave doing sound. We’re here in Roman Empire studios in Regina, Saskatchewan and tonight we’ve got no guest. We were going to have Matt Dillahunty on but due to a scheduling issue he was unable to join us tonight. We knew it was tenuous but we were hoping for the best. So, you just get us tonight and we may as well hop into the woo report.

Aliens, Magic Rocks, and Super Toothpaste
Aliens, Magic Rocks, and Super Toothpaste

Support the show by becoming a Patron

you can listen to this episode >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>here

or you can download it >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>here

Woo Report

Angela’s story

Rene’s story’s story

The article starts off the same as many others, telling you the importance of dental hygiene. This isn’t controversial and oddly enough they actually provide a link to Colgate Professional. A bit weird sharing a toothpaste company link in an article from a chemophobe. Despite the first bit of legit info coming from a site for a toothpaste company the article goes on to talk about how toxic toothpaste is and shares a page from in an effort to convince you of the terrible ingredients within.

Triclosan is an antibacterial and antifungal agent. triclosan has been shown to help prevent gingivitis. The mercola article makes some hefty claims about the dangers of triclosan but then ends it with the statement that “people who brushed their teeth with Colgate Total had more than five times as much triclosan in their urine as those who did not” Which stands to reason because that means the body is passing the triclosan through after it cleans the mouth and enters the system.

Sodium Lauryl Sulfate anionic detergent and surfactant found in many personal care products. Basically it’s a foaming agent. Aspartame is the artificial sweetener in most toothpastes. And it doesn’t do any of the bad things that mercola thinks it does. One of the most amusing parts of this section of the mercola article is the end where they list symptoms of methanol poisoning. And of course Fluoride, which is the scapegoat of all the crazy natural health bullshit sites. There are more ingredients but I didn’t have the time to go through them all in detail. Needless to say, a simple google search or wiki search can tell you the facts about everything that the chemophobe crowd is afraid of.

Then of course, comes the ingredients for the all natural pure bullshit toothpaste

Ingredients: 1 Tablespoon Coconut Oil 1 Teaspoon or 2 Capsules Turmeric 1 to 2 Drops Peppermint Essential Oil

The original article makes some claims about he benefits of the ingredients. First it claims that turmeric is an anti inflammatory. I could find no reputable source that confirmed this but alternative health nuts often over inflate the benefits of turmeric for which there is very little evidence.

There’s coconut oil which is supposedly an anti bacterial agent an supposedly has an anti inflammatory effect as well. I couldn’t find any good sources that confirmed this.

Supposedly these two random ingredients are also supposed to have a whitening effect on you teeth which will reduce or remove the need for whitening toothpastes or strips. Which I’ve been led to believe in the past, are mostly marketing hype anyway. I’ll add some of the links I looked at in the show notes. Nuttery

Destin’s Story’s story

extra religious story

Music break –


I Digress by Big Wreck

The Parapet of memory burns to the ground taking heaven with it by A Lost State of Mind, Listen Here


Jesus Built My Hotrod by Ministry 

Main topic - Gretta Vosper; the atheist pastor in the United Church of Canada. We're hoping to interview her soon.

Skepticism 101 part 11: Breaking down the logical fallacies part 5

Argument from silence (argumentum ex silentio) – where the conclusion is based on the absence of evidence, rather than the existence of evidence

To make an argument from silence (Latin: argumentum ex silentio) is to express a conclusion that is based on the absence of statements in historical documents, rather than on presence. Generally speaking, absence of evidence is not evidence; however, there are many cases where the reason evidence is being held back can be seen as evidence.

A good example of this is what many consider the mythicist position on Jesus. There is no evidence for his existence where we would expect it. It is considered a logical fallacy to therefore assume that the lack of evidence counts towards the positive assertion that jesus did not exist.

Agnostics and theists often claim that atheists are using this fallacy to arrive at the atheist conclusion, ignoring that we are not actually making a positive claim.

Last example is conspiracy theories who rely on the lack of evidence to count as evidence that something sinister is going on. The cover up proves the conspiracy.

Atheism for Dummies part 10

Religion for atheists part 4 – Hinduism

Hinduism is the major religion in India, and has around 900 million adherents. It is a monotheistic religion that looks like a polytheistic religion. The main god is Brahman but has many minor aspects. They believe that humans are in bondage to ignorance and illusion with the purpose to break the cycle of rebirth or to at least improve their station in the next life with the cycle continuing until one gains enlightenment. Hinduism is the religion that spawned the insufferable concepts of karma and yoga which have been twisted into even more bullshit by western culture. Their holy texts consist of the Vedas, the Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita, and the Ramayana. The Ramayana (/rɑːˈmɑːjənə/; Sanskrit: रामायणम्, Rāmāyaṇam, pronounced [rɑːˈmɑːjəɳəm]) is a Sanskrit epic poem ascribed to the Hindu sage and Sanskrit poet Valmiki. It is regarded as one of the two great works of Indian literature, along with the Mahabharata

Outro music is I Know It Meant Nothing, It Just Meant All The Wrong Things To Me. I'm still Sinking. I Wish I Could Tell You How Bad This Really Is by A Lost State of Mind

So that’s where we’re going to end the episode. We’ll record another half hour for the patreon page but you can join us for the next live broadcast by watching for our events on That link, along with many other relevant links will be in the show notes at either or with new episodes at

We appreciate your support and if you want the extra content from after the live show then go and become a patron at I want to mention how important it is that people support the show in one way or another, whether by sharing the episodes, sending your feedback, writing a review and rating us on your favorite podcatcher, or donating through patreon or paypal.  We’re always just one bad month away from not being able to run the show so everything you can do to show your support helps. Thanks to Dave for our intro music, thanks to Alix Capper Murdoch for doing the voice over for the intro and for some of our ads, and thank you to Jason Comeau for our outro music. You can find his stuff at All music played is either with permission or under the SOCAN licence to play. For more information on SOCAN you can find the link on our website

Remember to check out brainstorm gear at or go to and click on the cafépress link.

A special thanks to everyone who’s talked about and shared the conference info. In particular this week, a thanks to Trav from Bi Any Means and the crew from the Scathing Atheist. Everyone who spreads the word makes this even more likely to be successful. Remember to get your tickets before April 15th to ensure the best price. You can use the code Secular to get ten bucks off.

If you didn’t get a chance to contact us through the live chat going on during the episode but think you need to tell us something you can email us at or go to the website and click the contact tab. If you have a podcast or website and want a shoutout or have a promo to play let us know. And lastly, remember to give us a rating on your favorite podcatcher. More reviews and ratings give the show more exposure.

Thanks for listening and we’ll catch you again in a couple weeks.

Like us on Facebook, follow us on twitter Subscribe on Itunes or Stitcher (remember to give us a rating and write a review)

Donationsbrainstorm on amazon Become a patron

New Live Episodes at

" >
audible ad image
audible ad image

If I don't have the website updated fast enough and you want to see the show notes for the most recent episodes, you can check them out at