The Skeptic Studio
Oct. 14, 2016 Episode 56
Hi and welcome to the Brainstorm podcast Skeptic Studio where we do interviews, major topics, and news related to skepticism and atheism. I’m Cory and my panel tonight are Destin, Angela, Leo, and Rene, with the always amazing Dave doing sound. We’re here in Roman Empire studios in Regina, Saskatchewan and today is October 14th, 2016. The Skeptic Studio is brought to you by Reasonist Ink, atheist, skeptic, and science based apparel. You can find them at www.reasonistink.com. Tonight’s guest is Kavin Senapathy, she is an author, speaker, and science activist who writes about health, medicine, genomics, agriculture and food. She's the co-Executive Director of international pro-science, pro-biotech movement March Against Myths, and co-author of “The Fear Babe: Shattering Vani Hari’s Glass House,”. She's also a regular contributor to Forbes and The Genetic Literacy Project.
Support the show by becoming a Patron. You can get the full episode, ad free, and early on Patreon if you're a Patron.
(right click and 'save link as' to download)
as episodes are released there will be an embedded player in this post
Links from our chat with Uber
Check out Kavin's book on Amazon
Check out our sponsor: Absence of Clothing
Last week Justin Trudeau and his government announced a carbon tax minimum bench mark for the provinces of Canada to reach and hopefully exceed. This led to outrage among conservative Canadians, but none more than Brad Wall and his Sask party supporters. Many of these people are still climate change deniers. They say things like, “CO2 isn’t a pollutant”, or “Canada only produces 1.6% of the world’s CO2 emissions”. Some are still of the opinion that climates change and that this is all we’re seeing right now, normal changes.
It occurs to me that somehow every conservative in Canada must be a climate expert and that they should all take their research and findings to the IPCC and get the appropriate media attention. They’ve clearly found something that the vast majority of climate scientists haven’t. I know they all have their numbers, I already mentioned Canada’s contribution to CO2 emissions being only 1.6%, or they have their cherry picked stats from select years or select segments of years. They have arguments about parts per million in the atmosphere and they have one or two self proclaimed experts to back them up. There are even a couple organizations with the word science in their name to lend credibility to all of their data. If that sounds familiar, then you’ve been paying attention to the evolution debate that’s going on with creationists.
I’m not an expert, this is why I listen to people who are and right now the scientific consensus is that climate change is real, is happening, and is caused by human use of fossil fuels. The only number that matters to me as a layman, is 97%. That’s 97% of climate research points at and agrees with the conclusion that the burning of fossil fuels by humans is the main cause of climate change and that it needs to be addressed by at least a reduction in emissions and if possible, a removal of already present emissions from the atmosphere. It’s important to not that this is not just some poll, taken by a bunch of scientists. This is not merely their opinion, though there have been polls done and the number of climate researchers who agree about climate change is at least 97%. This consensus is a consensus of real data and research. This is enough to demonstrate that beyond a shadow of a doubt, climate change is real.
If you have a better plan than a carbon tax, then point it out. If you have a solution, then fill society in. If you’re just going to keep denying that we’re polluting, if you’re just going to keep spreading the lies propagated by the fossil fuel industry and their non scientist, hired experts, then shut the fuck up and let the rest of us try to solve the problem.
The music Break
This is where we’ll take the break for music. For Live listeners and Patrons you can enjoy the next few minutes and then we’ll be back. For regular feed subscribers this is where we’ll end the skeptic studio. I hope you enjoyed it. Remember to subscribe on Itunes, google play or some other podcatcher and check out the show notes at Theskepticstudio.com. we’ll have shift to reason radio for you next week.. If you can’t wait for it then listen live at www.Spreaker.com/show/brainstorm-podcast or go become a patron at www.Patreon.com/brainstormpodcast. So here’s the music break – Bring the Ruckus by Wutang Clan in honor of Luke Cage coming out on Netflix, 2nd sucks by A day to remember because it’s awesome and , A Metal cover of Sail originally by Awolnation but the cover is by Frog Leap Studios. So, enjoy and we’ll see you in a few minutes.
If you buy it from this link the artist gets a bit more money than from Itunes. https://loudr.fm/release/sail-metal-cover/HHGec
Here's a link to his website for more info on Leo and how to get his content or support him
Shift To Reason Radio
To those listening live or to our patrons, welcome back. For those listening weekly, welcome to Shift To Reason radio the Brainstorm production that focuses on science outreach and education. We’ll try our hand at teaching you a little bit about common skeptical topics, logical fallacies and errors in reasoning, as well as a bit about some religious apologetics. This episode is brought to you by audible.com, sign up for your free trial membership and free audiobook at audibletrial.com/brainstorm.
· A site called second nexus claims that “New Research Establishes That Intelligence Is Inherited from The Mother”
· Supposedly linked to the X chromosome
· “children are more likely to inherit intelligence from their mothers because intelligence genes are located on the X chromosomes (and mothers have two).”
· Mother’s do have to X chromosomes
· Not identical – doesn’t actually double the likelihood of a particular gene passing to the child
· Mothers pass only one X onto their children
· Father passes on either an X or Y which determines sex
· Whatever is on the X from the mother can pass to the child
· The father can also pass an X onto a daughter
· The double X that a girl child gets is adjusted downward – each cell turns off most of one of the X chromosomes
· So even if something does pass on via the X chromosome, it may not manifest because of the way some cells shut down part of the X
· Everyone has an X
· Short of a deletion, everyone gets the genes that are on that chromosome
· The Second Nexus site is really talking about a gene variant that may be linked with intelligence, not just genes
· Estimates that half of what we consider intelligence is inherited
· Intelligence is comprised of many genetic variants
· Environmental factors also play a role
· Not just your mother, not just the X, not even just genes
Featured podcast of the week: The Bi Any Means Podcast
Check out our sponsor: Absence of Clothing
Common Skeptical Topics
Pyramid Schemes and multi level marketing
Breaking down the logical fallacies 14
Equivocation – the misleading use of a term with more than one meaning (by glossing over which meaning is intended at a particular time)
in common parlance it is used in a variety of contexts, when discussed as a fallacy, equivocation only occurs when the arguer makes a word or phrase employed in two (or more) different senses in an argument appear to have the same meaning throughout.han one meaning or sense (by glossing over which meaning is intended at a particular time).
A feather is light.
What is light cannot be dark.
Therefore, a feather cannot be dark.
All jackasses have long ears.
Carl is a jackass.
Therefore, Carl has long ears.
The fallacy of equivocation occurs when a key term or phrase in an argument is used in an ambiguous way, with one meaning in one portion of the argument and then another meaning in another portion of the argument.
The laws imply lawgivers. There are laws in nature. Therefore there must be a cosmic lawgiver
Using an ambiguous term in more than one sense, thus making an argument misleading
Atheism for Dummies part 20 – Apologetics part 8
· Also known as the argument from design
· The universe is an astoundingly complex but highly ordered system
· the world appears fine-tuned to provide exactly the right conditions for the development and sustenance of life
· complexity makes natural explanations unsatisfactory
· There’s some very interesting history to this argument including use by Saint Thomas Aquinas
· Basically the opposite of evolution which shows that despite the appearance of complexity or design there can be a natural explanation
· Does not lead to any particular god but only to a kind of intelligent creator
· The argument of Intelligent Design and Fine Tuning are newer versions
“”But of course any God capable of intelligently designing something as complex as DNA/protein replicating machine must have been at least as complex and organized as the machine itself. Far more so if we suppose him additionally capable of such advanced functions as listening toprayers and forgiving sins. To explain the origin of the DNA/protein machine by invoking a supernatural Designer is to explain precisely nothing, for it leaves unexplained the origin of the Designer. You have to say something like "God was always there", and if you allow yourself that kind of lazy way out, you might as well just say "DNA was always there", or "Life was always there", and be done with it.
“This is rather as if you imagine a puddle waking up one morning and thinking, 'This is an interesting world I find myself in — an interesting hole I find myself in — fits me rather neatly, doesn't it? In fact it fits me staggeringly well, must have been made to have me in it!”
Listener Feedback and shoutouts
No new patrons this week. Remember folks, if we get up to 25 bucks per episode then I’ll make videos out of our interviews, post them to YouTube and add an entire section of show notes for just the interviews. We’re only 4 bucks short.
by atheistmom 5 stars
What a fun bunch! I love how they are so skeptical, and willing to change their views based on evidence.
Will sent us an email letting us know that the dead baby jokes were not over the line but were so funny he got a headache and almost blacked out because he couldn’t breathe from laughing so hard. He also sent a diagram of his cubical environment. I think he must be disturbing at least 6 people when he listens to our show.
Email Address: firstname.lastname@example.org
Subject: Tumor Research you mentioned
Message: I was listening to your show when I heard you talk about immunoresearch with cancer cells. It just so happens Lauren Udhe (aka The Biology Babe) is a graduate student who is working on that very study in Portland. She is on Facebook as Biology Babe if you want to ever look her up. I interviewed her on my own show a couple weeks ago and she is a fabulous guest that will talk your ear off!
Good luck and keep up the great show!
Plug your stuff
Links for Angela's stuff
Links for Destin's Stuff
Links for Rene's Stuff
Links for Leo's Stuff
Links for Cory's Stuff
So that’s where we’re going to end the episode. Before we go I want to make sure to mention our website, Brainstormblog.net. We have comprehensive show notes, including any notes that I’ve made regarding my stories and any notes that the rest of the crew gives me for theirs.
Shift to reason update – No updates
Get bonus content, full length ad free episodes and other bonuses by becoming a patron at Patreon.com/brainstormpodcast, just like Darryl, Will, Rob, Nathan, Destin, and now George and Stephanie
You can join us for the next live broadcast by following us on Spreaker. Just enter Brainstorm Podcast into the Spreaker search bar or you can go to our website brainstormblog.net and check out the live show page and the upcoming events page.
I was super wrong about when the AB secular conference is. It’s October 15th and 16th. That’s this weekend. I hope you made it and have a great time. https://www.facebook.com/ABSecularConference/?fref=ts
Remember to rate us and write a review on iTunes or Stitcher and hit that subscribe button. If you leave a review then let us know and remember to tell us where you’re from so we know which store on itunes to look in.
Thanks to Dave for our intro music, thanks to Alix Capper Murdoch for doing the voice over for the intro and for some of our ads, and thank you to Jason Comeau for our outro music. You can find his stuff at www.aloststateofmind.com
All music played is either with permission or under the SOCAN licence to play. For more information on SOCAN you can check out the music license info on our website brainstormblog.net
T-shirts, mugs, and other cool shit is available at www.cafepress.ca/brainstormpodcastgear
We love to hear from our listeners so shoot us an email at email@example.com or go to our website and hit that contact page. If you have a podcast or website and want a shout out or have a promo to play let us know. We are also offering advertising to podcasts, bands, people, and organizations on the website. Contact us for rates and options.
Thanks for listening and we’ll see you in a couple weeks when we bring on our new crew member; Lisa to see how she likes being part of the crew.