Transphobia and Social Justice with Marissa McCool
The Skeptic Studio
March 6, 2017 Brainstorm #66 - The Skeptic Studio #12
Hi and welcome to the Brainstorm Podcast Skeptic Studio where we do interviews and have an open discussion on a topic related to current events or critical thinkin. I’m Cory and my panel tonight are Leo, Lisa, Angela and Rene, with the always amazing Dave doing sound. We’re here in Roman Empire studios in Regina, Saskatchewan and today is March 3rd, 2017. We broadcast live at 8:30 pm Central Standard Time every second Friday on Spreaker.com Tonight’s guest is Marissa McCool, host of the Inciting Incident podcast, blogger for Lords of Pain.net and author of the PC Lie: How American Voters Decided I Don’t Matter.
You can listen to The Skeptic Studio >>>>>>
or you can download it >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
You can listen to the Shift To Reason Radio >
or you can download it >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Featured podcast of the week: Promoting Secular Feminism
Shift To Reason Radio
MARCH 13, 2017 BRAINSTORM #66 - SHIFT TO REASON RADIO #10
In this episode Cory, Destin, Leo, Lisa, Angela, Rene, and the amazing Dave talk about Robert Deniro's opinions on vaccines, some witches casting spells at Donald Trump, a teacher in Ontario teaching falsehoods about vaccines, Google removing Natural News from search results, and the Federalist thinks liberals are hypocrites on science. Plus we cover a logical fallacy and a religious apologetic.
eatured podcast of the week: Bi Any Means Podcast
Breaking down the logical fallacies #17
Fallacy of Division - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy_of_division
A fallacy of division occurs when one reasons logically that something true for the whole must also be true of all or some of its parts
Inferring that something is true of one or more of the parts from the fact that it is true of the whole. This is the opposite of the fallacy of composition.
o A is part of B
o B has property X
o Therefore, A has property X.
o His house is about half the size of most houses in the neighborhood, therefore, his doors must all be about 3 1/2 feet high
o I heard that the Catholic Church was involved in a sex scandal cover-up. Therefore, my 102 year-old Catholic neighbor, who frequently attends Church, is guilty as well!
Variation: The ecological fallacy or ecological inference fallacy focuses on statistical data. For example, if the Giants are doing poorly this year, it would be fallacious to conclude that every member on the team is doing poorly.
Atheism for Dummies
The Transcendental Argumenthttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcendental_argument_for_the_existence_of_God
The Transcendental Argument for the Existence of God (TAG) is the argument that attempts to prove God's existence by arguing that logic, morals, and science ultimately presuppose a supreme being, and that God must be the source of logic and morals
o God (most often God is defined as the supreme entity found in Christianity), is a necessary precondition for knowledge (logical reasoning, morality)
o People know things (have logical, and moral intuitions)
o Therefore, God exists
Can you see the problem with this? Of course you can, this doesn’t prove shit. It just asserts that god exists because god exists.
The logic objection
o If logic is created by or contingent on god then god can change the principles of logic at it’s whim.
o That means that god can change the laws of identity so that they’re invalid
o Which means statements would no longer be themselves. Which is false
o If logic is contingent on god then to argue that god cannot change them takes away omnipotence
o Therefore the claim that logic is dependant on god is false
The science objection
o Science presupposes that natural law has always operated as it operates at present and that there have been no violations of such laws
o Christianity presupposes a type of god that performs miracles
o Miracles are by definition a violation of the natural laws
o Therefore, science presupposes the non existence of any miracle giving gods
o If the argument is stated that the natural laws have not always been as they are then the scientific method and as a result, science need to be thrown out
o This removes all meaning from the statement that science presupposes god
o Throwing science out makes no sense because it works and the natural laws are what they are
o Therefore no miracle giving god who violates the laws of nature, exists
I think my favorite argument against morality coming from god is the modified Euthyphro dilemma
o Is what is morally good commanded by God because it is morally good, or is it morally good because it is commanded by God?"
o Basically the idea is that if something is good and that’s why god commands it, then good is independent of god
o And if something is good because it is demanded by god then it isn’t objective because god can change its mind and reverse the command
o In this vein, humanity is left with no direction as to what is truly morally good
o if morality presupposes god and moral obligations are dependent on the will of god then there are a couple problems
o Which god? This is pretty standard but there’s no way to tell which set of god beliefs one should get their morals from.
o If god created morality can he change it and if he can; does that not remove it from the category of objective?
o An objective moral standard would have to be independent of god and would as such apply to god’s actions
o It would have to be uniformly applicable to all actions and actors
o This implies that it cannot come from god
o If we accept that god created morality then we must accept that he can change it for if he can’t then it calls into question the omnipotence of said god
Thanks Lisa and Brother Brewer for being a patron.
The Wayward Atheists youtube channel version : https://youtu.be/95yMcr8sqcI
Brainstorm on the Skeptic's Brewpub: https://youtu.be/vAer3eoMLMc
So that’s the end of the episode an I just want to say sorry for the weird order that everything is in or the weird length of this one or actually for regular feed subscribers. This was a weird scenario where we weren’t in studio and we got started late and we had technical glitches all over the place. I hope that everything sounds ok and that you’ll join us next time
Make sure to check out the show notes on our website, brainstormblog.net.
You can get bonus content, full length ad free episodes and other bonuses by becoming a patron at Patreon.com/brainstormpodcast, just like Will, Darryl, Rob, Nathan, Destin, George, Stephanie, Janet, Aaron, Lisa, and Brother Brewer
Join us in two weeks for the next live broadcast on Spreaker. Just enter Brainstorm Podcast into the Spreaker search bar or you can go to our website brainstormblog.net and check out the live show page and the upcoming events page.
Remember to rate us and write a review on iTunes or Stitcher and hit that subscribe button. If you leave a review then let us know and remember to tell us where you’re from so we know which store on itunes to look in.
Thanks to Dave for our intro music, thanks to Alix Capper Murdoch for doing the voice over for the intro and for some of our ads, and thank you to Jason Comeau for our outro music. You can find his stuff at www.aloststateofmind.com
All music played is either with permission or under the SOCAN licence to play. For more information on SOCAN you can check out the music license info on our website brainstormblog.net
T-shirts, mugs, and other cool shit is available at www.cafepress.ca/brainstormpodcastgear
Thanks for listening and remember, the truth matters